I am a local of Ligonier, and the Wicked Googly was the best thing to ever happen to the local nightlife for twenty-somethings. The other bars of Ligonier are good, but more old-boy regulars sitting watching the game. The Googly shows sports on the tvs, but they also have live music and specials a few times a week. Once in awhile they get Creme Brulee on tap and I am in heaven. Pizza is good too. My one complaint is that the space is small (because it is in what used to be the arcade area of the bowling alley) so when there is a live band, don't plan on conversing with your friends because you will not be able to hear a word they say unless you are yelling in eachother's ears. Try to sit in the far booth instead of the tables closer to the door - you'll have a better chance of maintaining conversation.
If you own or manage The Wicked Googly, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.