We went with a reservation and wound up sitting around for 30 minutes. Initial serving of salad and soup was haphazard, The hibachi chef was not that skilled. A lot of the food that he tossed to customers wound up on the floor (and was not picked up afterwards. Food was okay, but I've seen better. There are a few other Japanese places in town I;d try before returning here.
If you own or manage Tokyo Diner, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.