I wanted to love the Supper Club. I was thrilled to find such a lovely restaurant and the staff was very nice. On a recent Saturday night, the bartender was overworked but very friendly. He definitely needed help behind the bar. The wine was excellent. Two people dined and we were underwhelmed by the food. We ordered the hummus plate for starters which was shockingly bad. The roasted veggies were simply dried like leather, no taste. The hummus gritty and tasteless. I can barely cook but even I can roast vegetables w a better flavor profile. The Broccoli soup was OK, overall the best dish. The allegedly famous tator tots were very bland. We ordered 2 sandwiches. The lamb was very bland and the chicken w Brie Apple and Carmelized Onion was served on stale bread. The chicken was dry and rubbery and totally lacking in taste. I asked for a doggy bag and actually did feed the chicken ( which was a lot like jerky, just like the roasted veggies) to the dog. Must have been the chefs night off. Serving food that subpar is inexcusable. Don't waste your money. This place has a 52% approval rating over at Urbanspoon. Wish I would have read those reviews before going. I'm very sad I dropped hard earned cash there.
If you own or manage The Supper Club, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.