I have stayed at this B&B several times (my sister lives in the area) and found it to an outstanding place to stay. My wife and I stay at B&Bs whenever we travel and have only stayed at one (Lighthouse in the San Francisco bay) that we thought the breakfast was as good as what Joe and Gail provide, and that one cost us $200+ a night.
The rooms are nicely decorated with a relaxing home-like feel. The breakfast is better that you will get at most restaurants, and the best in the area.
I was shocked to see one bad report (“Extremely Disappointed” ), as that does not sound at all like the owners. I believe Gail's reasoning 100% and am shocked at the couple taking out their frustration on Frosty Hollow.
There are a few small rooms, as in any B&B in an old house, but the rest of the rooms as well as those in the Barn (didn't see a good photo of the barn) are a nice size. There are lots of common living room space in both buildings to sit and relax, and join in on a conversation if you want. You will not get a better room in the area with the exception for some at the Mill Stream which cost over $100. and you will not get the same atmosphere or breakfast as any B&B.
The breakfast and the company of the guests, as well as Gail and Joe are worth the price alone. I am so bummed that someone with an ax to grind about their company would cause the Frosty Hollow to be downgraded to less than a full five stars that they deserve.
See more room tips
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.