It is hard rating this since we had such drastically different experienced!
Six co-workers and I went to this restaurant twice in the two weeks I was working in Chambersburg. The first time we went the food was great! The six guys all had great service, but I was pretty much ignored (seemed to be a reoccuring theme at restaurants on this trip- I was the only female in the group of 7). The bread was not up to par with main dishes, but they were so good you forgot about the bread. The second time was a complete bust. We went earlier (around 2pm) and had a waiter who didn't know the menu and didn't seem to speak much English (most of the employees were Latino). I was brought out the wrong pasta, I ordered whole wheat penne and was given regular, which was amusing since he had just told a co-worker that they were out of regular penne! One of my co-workers had to get up to get drink refils and bread for the table. If you got a drink refil you had to ask for ice or you wouldn't get any. Just an all around bad experience the second time.
Oh, and a little warning also, the alfredo sauces seemed to make everyone sick both times we went. I had the Marsala and was fine, but several guys had Chicken or ham alfredo and were VERY sick.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.