This restaurant used to offer authentic and delicious Italian cuisine. On our last three visits in a short time span, we found the main dishes served with warmed over Rigatoni pasta (not al dente nor cooked to order), tasteless mushroom marinara sauce that was very acidic and with a scant amount of mushroom fragments and very stale garlic bread. We paid close to twenty dollars for two disappointing pasta meals. I don't think we'll be returning after patronizing this business for ten+ years.
If you own or manage Caretti's Pizza, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.