My wife and I really like this place. Odd combo of hipsters, old yuppies, and grunge types, but don't pay any mind to that (unless your'e allergic to old yuppies). The food is solid and the service has always been adequate.
My fav food is their chips/salsa (always really good) and a club sandwich. Good burgers and sweet potato fries as well. The have a great woodchuck cider too.
Can be really busy sometimes so I'd recommend going at an off time or deal with the fact you'll have to wait.
If you own or manage McNellie's Public House, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.