I have been to many different Greek restaurants over the years, and I have to say this was one of the least appetizing.
I ordered the gyro on a pita. The gyro meat was literally (and I'm not kidding here) SWIMMING in grease. Both my friend and I had the same problem, as we'd ordered the same meal.
Most places shave the meat off for each gyro, but here it's put in some kind of fry vat and let soak for who knows how long. It's really too bad, because flavor wise, it was decent. But having my pita soaked in grease from the dripping meat wasn't the makings of a good gyro. I could NOT get around how much grease was congealing at the bottom of my plate.
The portions were generous and the price wasn't bad, but why bother when it's such a gut bomb from all the grease? I was even nauseous afterward, and I've got an iron stomach.
Bottom line - I won't go back there again. I'll look for another spot to satisfy my Greek hunger.
If you own or manage Jim's Coney Island, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.