My wife and I visited here recently and were not very happy with the food. For starters, the menu selections are very limited. You cannot get smoked chicken on a 2 meat or 3 meat combo. My wife ordered pulled pork and chopped brisket. I had smoked sausage, chopped brisket and catfish.
The place is somewhat cramped. Even after asking for our table to be wiped off, I still had to remove some food pieces using the paper towels provided at each table.
When the food arrived, it was on a serving tray with butcher's paper (which was fine for me). Everything except the catfish was drowned in BBQ sauce. The sauce was entirly too sweet and too much. The excessive sauce covered all of the grease that was in the brisket (and my wife's pulled pork). It was also camoflauge in an attempt to hide the small portions. My wife had stomach trouble not long after we left from there due to the grease. The side orders were average.
Billy Ray's has a great reputation for their original BBQ joint in Tulsa. The Broken Arrow location does not live up to that reputation.
The ONLY recommendation that I can offer is the all-you-can-eat catfish on Tuesdays from 4 PM-10PM. If they have no liit on how much catfish you can have, they do fry some great catfish.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.