We dined with 10 in our party and didn't have reservations on a Friday night. The staff was friendly when seating us (even though we had a large party and hadn't called ahead). Our server was very friendly, making jokes with the jokesters in our party. The food was very good. No one had a complaint. Our orders ranged from Philly sandwiches to prime rib and even scallops and shrimp. The restaurant began to get very crowded, but we never felt rushed to move on, and we talked quite a bit before ordering and also after eating.
I would definitely go back when travelling through London, Ohio. (Just a few minutes off I-70 - worth the trip).
If you own or manage Red Brick Tavern, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.