We were just driving through Logan and it was dinnertime, so decided to stop at The Olde Dutch. I didn't expect much; I've eaten at numerous "Amish-themed" restaurants and they are all pretty much the same. The Olde Dutch had more of the same, but also the option to order off the menu. I had turkey, which was plentiful and moist. Husband had Liver 'n' Onions, which he said was very well prepared.
The buffet line was very busy and while often restocked, no one took the time to clean up around it. Thus, spilled food was quite prevalent; I stepped on croutons on the way out.
Service was quite good.
I did get a bit of an "outsider" vibe, as we were driving a foreign car and dressed differently from the predominantly local crowd. No one was rude, but there were a number of stares from other patrons. I don't mind that sort of thing, but I know that others do.
In short, if it's the right time of day as we're in the area, we'd stop again. There aren't many non-fast food options in this area of Ohio.