We came for a week-long visit at Kelleys Island. The Pump was the first place we ate at and we enjoyed it so much, we ended up returning three more times. Their perch was the best fish, on the island or on mainland! The breading was so light and fluffy and crispy, and the fish was soft and white and flakey. Also, good crabcakes and chicken wings, (their weekly special). Also, their famous Brandy Alexander was pretty good too... like a cross between a Mudslide and eggnog. We had really pretty good service. The bartender was a little rough around the edges, but we always got our food hot and fast. The prices were fair (not overpriced), and we got a good view of the lake.
If you own or manage The Village Pump, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.