Let me preface by saying I would have given the restaurant a 5, but I'm a vegetarian. There was one pasta dish on the menu that was veg friendly, and the only other option was to order al a carte veggies or apps. Surely Columbus's top restaurants can start to get a little more creative when it comes to vegetarian entrees!
With that being said, if I was a meat eater, WHAT A MENU! Some old steakhouse classics, some fun twists on dishes - I would have had a hard time deciding what to order. My husband has the ribeye and really loved it. Cooked to perfection, and he also enjoyed the mac and cheese.
Also, our waiter was great, too.
The *only* issue we had was that we showed up a few minutes late for our 6:45 reservation (it was our 5 year wedding anniversary). We get up to the hostess stand, and the girl there was on the phone with someone and looked like she was reading the menu over the phone. I'm sure she was caught up with someone asking a ton of questions, but she never acknowledged we were even standing there - no nod and smile or a "just a minute!" to let us know she would help when ready. We stood there with a line forming behind us for almost 5 minutes. Finally, a waiter came up and asked if he could help us. We told him we were there for our reservation, and he asked if we would like to sit inside or outside. Since the weather was fantastic, we said "oh! outside would be great!" He told us to go outside and head down the sidewalk and the hostess there would help us. What he neglected to tell us is that our reservation doesn't carry to the patio, and there were 8 tables ahead of us in line. Did I mention I am 8 months pregnant too? Ugh. We head back to the front host stand IN the restaurant and get back in line behind all the other people that were waiting. Luckily there was someone new at the desk, so we just said we had a 6:45 res, and she took us right to our table inside. Le sigh. A mild service hiccup I guess, but I would have expected a bit more from someplace like Lindey's!
If you own or manage Lindey's, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.