An American style diner in Castleton is a strange choice but it looks well done as you walk in, enough to tempt you to sit down. But as is often the case the toilets appear to be an after-thought, all clean but really shabby and untidy. And this tells you everything you need to know, because if the attention to detail is lacking here then it's probably also lacking when it comes to other things - like the quality of the ingredients.
So buddy's is a case of all show and little go with average catering style burgers, hot-dogs and fries at average prices. Nothing that wrong but also absolutely no reason to go back or recommend it to others. Get rid of all the Americana, serve a really good burger in a simple cafe style, and concentrate on getting all the little things right.
If you own or manage Buddy's, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.