My brother-in-law told me that this was the best restaurant in Chapel Hill. While it was good, we may have had too high expectations.
The decor is interesting -- early 50's cafe complete with counter service. The decor was at odds with the prices -- $20 here, $21 there. there was a back covered patio that we did not venture on to that held more patrons and looked interesting.
The signature dish -- shrimp and grits -- was good. But it wasn't sublime. In fact, there weren't too many grits on my plate. It seemed like a simple dish: shrimp, grits, mushrooms and scallions. Again, good, but not great. We also had tomato & rice soup -- okay, but then I'm not a tomato soup fan unless it's gazpacho. We also had the combination BBQ plate -- pulled pork, collared greens, etc. that was also good.
In general, the food was good, but in my opinion, not deserving of the high praise from my brother-in-law or the other reviewers on this site.
If you own or manage Crook's Corner, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.