It was a very nice dinner, but unfortunately didn't blow us away as we expected it would (perhaps wrongfully so). Both my wife and I had the filet, and both were near well-done (ordered medium). In fairness, they did offer to remake the steaks, but they were still fairly juicy and tasted pretty good. Prices were very high and our bill ended up over $100 with us splitting desert and only one alcoholic drink. Tried our friends' tuna, which was quite good and the shrimp and grits was very good, according to another friend. Our desert was okay; we shared a chocolate cake creation. The cake didn't taste freshly made and was a bit dense.
If you own or manage Cafe Pamlico, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.