We visited Memorial Day weekend, and while I recognize that it was a busy weekend and we had a medium sized group of 6, the service was pretty terrible. The poor hostess looked like she was on her own and ended up bussing tables instead of working with the guests. Tables remained dirty and empty for upward for 15 minutes while impatient guest waited.
Luckily, the food was excellent, which made our visit bearable. The server, however, brought out a side dish that was not ordered, because they apparently ran out of the original dish. Instead of asking which replacement dish we would like, he simply picked one and did not offer to bring a menu or for a new dish to be chosen until I suggested he do so.
I would try it one more time just to make sure I didn't just hit them on an off night, but I'll also be sure to call early and make a reservation. (We tried to make a reservation this time, but they said they weren't taking any more at that time.)
I do have to say the view is beautiful and I can see how it would be a nice romantic getaway if the service improved.
If you own or manage Front Street Grill at Stillwater, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.