Reviewers here are mistaking Kerrigan's Pub (the former "Magic's Pub" with Dee Angelo's Pleasant Avenue Cafe. The good reviews are for Dee's! The bad reviews are for Kerrigan's Pub.
Dee's is in a quaint old house on the east end of Main St. The atmosphere is country Italian and the food is better than good. There is outdoor dining in the warmer months. Dee's is the best Italian food in Westhampton Beach offering a full range of appetizers, pastas, secondis and dolcis. The bar is friendly and capably tended by Lenny. Service is excellent and prices are pretty standard for relatively high end Italian in the Hamptons. The breads come from Arthur Ave. in the Bronx and are worth the calories.
Contrary to the tag this is not a Mexican restaurant. Kerrigan's Pub is a block west on Main St and, while there is some shared ownership between the two restaurants they are miles apart in quality, concept, ambience, etc. Pleasant Ave. Cafe is well worth a vist...Kerrigan's Pub, not so much.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.