My wife & I (well-travelled and an unassuming couple), stayed in this exclusive 5* residence for a period of 9 days (half board) on the recommendation of my trusted travel agent having included this stay as part of a 3 week holiday (South Africa plus safari and on to Mauritius).
Hotel architecture, rooms and ambience, were as anticipated given the rating; the staff were accommodating and were generally very eager to appear friendly, as we are ourselves. The deposit of a previously discarded apple core in or room upon arrival was certainly disappointing and was given back to Reception; interestingly it was ‘accepted’ without any apology offered.
The first evening meal, shortly after our (latish) arrival included in the menu, loin of lamb. “How would I wish this to be cooked” I was asked? “Well done and without blood” was the reply. The lamb duly arrived and at the first cut demonstrated running blood! This was immediately returned with obvious explanation and I awaited further additional heat to quell the haemorrhage. Unfortunately the 2nd attempt did nothing to stem the flow as the meat remained ‘rare’ and oozing with the ‘red stuff’. It was sent back to the chef with adequate explanation, at which point my appetite had been extinguished and no further meal was consumed. The explanation given was that to cook the meat to MY request would be to render the meat tough and dry; that I fully understood but as I (surprisingly for lamb) had been asked initially how I wished the meat to be cooked, I had thought that the least that would be served was a dish to MY preference.
That was only the start! So then further problems - we were asked if either of us had any dietary issues to divulge? “Yes”, an allergy to mussels was notified; “Not a problem” and this was understood by the restaurant staff; point made! Trying to engage with Mauritius and its culture we ‘booked’ a Mauritian meal (24 hours’ notice required). As the meal included a seafood ragout we re-iterated forcefully my wife’s mussel allergy and this element was duly noted, being heartily assured the matter was in hand. Surprise! Guess what was served as the first course? Despite the plate being put in front of my wife with the verbal statement “No mussels” by the server, there indeed was at least one large mussel. Red faces ++++. Needless to say, the dish was re-prepared, this time ‘sans moules’. Too late, the bubble had burst and the defective communication within the staff members was further exposed.
Needless to say, the not insubstantial ‘supplementary’ charges were waived and we received wine without charge in an attempt at reparations.
The following morning, I felt it obligatory to speak with the General Manager and give direct feedback concerning the events of the previous experience. I requested from Reception details of the said name and route of access and was given his card. Unsurprisingly the gentleman was already on the lookout for us and was eager to understand the detail of our plight. We chatted well and extensively in a thoroughly low key manner, pointing out our observations/feedback that whilst being friendly to guests, the staff seemed to miss the point of ordering food and precisely noting the detail of the order.
A robust meeting with the staff was held with the Manager (as we observed) and we assumed the ‘blip’ would become a historical matter and forgotten by us. Whoops; the following morning we were again presented with breakfast dishes that were not ‘as offered’ by the waiting on staff who although (mentally) noting our order, had not re-iterated the food order to confirm the appropriate detail. The meal did not live up to expectation therefore; disappointing given the (self-proclaimed) major status of the establishment.
We had further friendly rapport with the Manager (at his instigation) who was shocked and disappointed with the service we had received, especially after our previous dialogue.
I do not wish to labour the point but if staying at a 5* hotel (as we often do), there is an expectation of an appropriate level of service.
A further minor matter also comes to mind; a complimentary bottle of water was available only upon the day of our arrival and not further offered. A ‘standard procedure’ there, as we were informed!
I must complete the review by adding that our departure was enhanced by a (duly accepted) offer of an individual late afternoon Mauritian meal, prepared and served to us adjacent to the beach at an arranged timing of 4pm. This consisted of an exceptional array of Mauritian cuisine, completely superb with fantastic and individual service by ‘Avi’; probably the most outstanding (and young) staff member encountered during our stay.
So what more can I say? The ambience and surroundings are superb however the amenities of the sister hotel (just across the road, Casuarina Hotel) were not advertised at all but as we are gregarious, we found these for ourselves (including a shop) and enjoyed several nights of entertainment (live music, dancing and demonstrations of local custom) with the reduced prices for drinks an added bonus!
We are an innately positive couple and would not let the circumstances we experienced detract from our overall enjoyment of the stay but if this residence is to maintain its own advertised standards then attention to basic detail must be taken seriously.
The general lack of choice of Mauritian cuisine was glaringly overt within the menu, despite an ‘option’ to engage with 1 or maybe 2 local dishes on a nightly basis there was a requirement to book 24 hours in advance for a fully ‘local’ meal experience - disappointing.
The Manager advised us that many/most guests choose ‘haut cuisine’ dishes rather than local food and that is the reason for the limited local dishes. Note our own findings in this respect! What a shame - stay elsewhere other than this establishment if that is your preference; let the Mauritians celebrate their unique culture. NB take note from where the winner of UK ‘Masterchef’ originates from this year?!
Thank you for reading this honest appraisal, we are very likely to return to Mauritius but not necessarily stay in the same hotel - unless of course changes are evident to engage with Mauritian culture.
All rooms appear to benefit from sea views and are very well appointed
See more room tips
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.
Report response as inappropriate
We wish to extend our deepest thanks to your good person for your general comments following your stay at our Five Star Resort and appreciate to have put us in high rating.
However, we wish to bring some complementary comments as follows:
1.Our Housekeeping team are very keen and devoted in the maintenance of a high standard of cleanliness in our room and public area, especially the “Turn Down” at 18.00 hours. The Executive Chef heartily apologized on behalf of the whole team for the left over piece of apple you found in the decorative bowl in your room –which was covered.
2. Our heartfelt apologies for the misunderstanding as regards to the mussels and the fact that your spouse is allergic to it, this was our mistake and we again apologise for this hiccup. As far as the lamb is concerned, you will subscribe with me that the “Loin of Lamb” cannot be well done right in the middle and in so doing, the same will be dark burnt .Still the chef has done his level best to satisfy you although he did explain the difficulty in cooking this tender meat, he had to cut it into two halves to ensure that it will be well done.
After my trip abroad and having taken cognizance of the problematic situation at the Cardinal Exclusive Resort. I made it a solemn duty to meet your good person in view of settling the matter.
We carried out a commercial gesture in your favour and that of your wife by offering you a dinner with drinks at the beach restaurant and lunch on your departure date followed by a late check out - all on a complimentary basis .
Our Executive Chef having very wide experience in the field is always attentive to the varied tastes and expectations of our guest and above all takes much pleasure to satisfy them all.
Our menu cards(both for lunch & dinner) is composed of a wide variety of meals(inclusive of mauritian dishes) to meet the expectations of guests of cosmopolitan origins. Please be assured that we took good note of your valuable comments to have a larger variety of Mauritian dishes in view of celebrating our unique culture.
As regards to the bottle of water, our policy is to offer a free bottle on the first day as welcoming gesture , but is for sale henceforth in your mini bar.
On your departure day, your spouse & yourself seemed very satisfied with your stay at our hotel.
We were particularly happy to note that you have enjoyed the ambiance of our sister hotel , you even mentioned to our team members at the reception , that you would write “Personally” to me the General Manager.
As good professionals, we thought that this matter has been solved to the satisfaction of both parties.
This response is the subjective opinion of the management representative and not of TripAdvisor LLC.