My wife and I were there yesterday, a Friday, and a beautiful day in the Hamptons.
We stopped at 75 Main for lunch, my wife had heard there was a new chef, and wanted to check it out.
After my experience yesterday, and after having read other reviews after the fact, maybe I should not feel too bad.
We ordered the same thing, the salmon blt. The dish came with the sandwich on wheat toast, a basket of fries, and a bit of lettuce, tomato and red onion on the side.
Sounds good right?
When I went to lift a bit of onion to put into my sandwich as my wife had suggested, I saw movement. Yes, there was a bug on my plate! My wife said it looked to be a beetle.
Who knows, I'm no entomologist, all I know is this was a real turn off!
We called our waitress, Ivana, who offered another plate, but I declined.
I should have brought it to the attention of the manager, and I didn't. We were very close to other diners and did not want to make a scene.
But I did expect a complimentary drink, or a adjusted check,- even a apology. That didn't happen!
To me, that sort of thing is inexcusable, especially in a 'high end' restaurant with the sort of reputation 75 Main is supposed to have.
After all is said and done, the food was not bad. It is somewhat pricey, which I would wouldn't be too concerned about if this incident were not so poorly handled.
It'll be quite some time if I ever go back, if at all.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.