Visiting Shelter Island in the middle of the week during the off-season, we didn't have much of a selection of eating establishments. But we're glad that Sweet Tomato's was one of only a few options, because we had a great night out. From the friendly staff, quality food and lovely music, we enjoyed ourselves so much that we came back the next night for a drink and dessert. The grilled calamari was especially excellent, and their homemade mint chocolate chip gelato was simply divine! The prices aren't cheap, but I think that goes for most of the restaurants on Shelter Island.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.