I was in town with my old college roommate this past August to visit other college friends in the Port Jeff/Central Islip/Huntington area and we had a hard time finding a hotel reasonably priced on Long Island. Search no more! Aunt Betty's B&B was worth the money! It was quiet, we had AC, and she provides a very homey environment! We stayed in Room #3 with the bathroom across the hall - which I thought would be weird, but it wasn't at all. Everything was immaculate and clean. The bed was soft and comfy. Her guests were fun to talk to as we all ate breakfast at her kitchen table that next morning. She made us toast with cut out stars and an egg through it. It was very yummy!
Betty herself is very down to earth and real. You can tell she loves what she does. She's got a very cool backyard with lots to look at as well. We enjoyed her stories.
The location is wicked close to Downtown Port Jeff. Pretty convenient. She also gives good directions and great pens too! I've had them for four months and they write very well! :)
I have to say - all the TripAdvisor reviews matched our experience. Definitely recommend it if you're in town for the weekend!