I would agree that it is a little bit expensive but the gelato is so delicious, it is worth it! We were introduced to Eugenio's by our friend who has celiacs. All of Eugenio's gelatos are gluten free, which is great for so many people these days who suffer from celiacs. I have tried a few of the flavors (salted caramel and stracciatella to name a few) and they are all just the best thing ever. The stracciatella is a sweet cream gelato and it has what I believe is chocolate ganache running through it. I've never been able to try other flavors as long as they still have my stracciatella when I'm there. The salted caramel is good too but it runs out quick if you get there after the crowd.
It is a very small place but there are a few tables inside and outside when its nice out to sit and enjoy. We were always served by the same girl when we went, she is very patient and willing to provide you a sample if you're not sure about what flavor you'd like. She always greets us with a smile, which is such a rare thing to find these days. They also have some baked goods and coffee of course, but I've only ever had the gelato. I wish it were summer all the time, because then I'd be at Eugenio's having gelato all the time!
If you own or manage Saratoga Gelato, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.