After hearing are reading a lot about this place, decided to give it a try. It was quite busy for a mid week night. Bar is well stocked and drinks well made but very pricey. Menu is about what one would expect for an American style restaurant. One of us had a burger served on what appeared to be a store bought hamburger bun (which was too light for the sized burger and soggy to pick up) and some undercooked fried (try cutting them thinner) and a small overly wet side of cole slaw. Burger itself was too thick to serve medium rare without charring the outside (flame clearly too hot). Pickles straight from the jar! The other entrée was better but not overwhelming to make up for the overall kitchen quality issues. Most likely won't be back anytime soon.
If you own or manage Madison & Main, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.