Love the Eveready diner in Hyde Park. But something is amiss in Rhinebeck. Recently went to the diner with a large party for a special occasion. Ordered classic diner fare (hot turkey and mashed potato dinner). Somebody else in my party ordered the same thing. When the order came out, mine was a "hash" on top of stuffing, and my cousin's was what you would expect, sliced turkey. When I asked the waitress about this, she retorted "well, that's all that was left from the turkey" (meaning the scraps). To make matters worse, she was extremely apathetic and non apologetic. When I suggested I would eat it, but I felt I shouldn't be charged, she said "well if you eat it you are going to be charged". Once again, no apologies. When it was coffee time, she was annoyed about having to go back to the table and fill more cups. And when asked for a candle for my grandmothers 91st birthday, she quipped "we don't do birthdays". Total incompetency and arrogance. In my years as a server, I would have never treated the customer in this way. I got something to go for my daughter who was sick at home, and it was pretty disgusting (chicken tenders that were overdone and dry) Our family is pretty certain we will not be eating there again.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.