We were there on a hot summer day. Upon entering one does not know where to start.
The store is quite large. Ice cream, gelato, soft serve, fat free, bakery, nuts, sugar free chocolates, fudge, Jelly Bellies, candies, sugar free candy, cold drinks, make your own sundae. It is a dream come true. you name it and it will probably be here.
Be careful if you make your own sundae, it goes by weight. 39 cents per ounce sounds cheep but that is really $6.24 a pound. Some candy is pricey but most prices are reasonable and typical.
The shop is entertaining. One could walk around for a long time enjoying the sights, smells, and checking out candies not found in other shops. There is seating at the soda bar or sit outside to enjoy your ice cream or fudge. Out side trash barrels are needed or go back into the shop to toss.
I checked out the web site after visiting the shop. Great web site with good pictures. They also do mail order. If you go to Port Jefferson, this is one sight you should not miss.
If you own or manage The Port Jefferson Frigate, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.