My family and I visited Keuka lake this past Summer for three weeks. We were a pretty large crowd of 8+. We ate at Timmy G's twice and would have eaten there more times if we had "found it" sooner than half way through our vacation. Trying to please 8 people with one restaurant is tough and it was a unanimous decision to return to Timmy G's the second time. Between us all we probably had half the menu and no complaints. More importantly answers were yes, my meal was fabulous! Clearly the owners are active in their restaurant as it shows. Nice job Timmy G's! Great local eatery. Get specific directions how to get there. It is a little tricky and worst case go to the Topp's supermarket in Penn Yann and ask from there. If I recall correctly you could walk to the restaurant from Topp's but not easily seen from there.
If you own or manage Timmy G's, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.