Visited here last Sunday with wife, daughter, her husband & 2 granddaughters while the Long Island Fair was in progress. Lots going on, good outdoor entertainment, music & food-stalls available and the weather was great too; excellent displays of local crafts - quilts, photography and artwork to see as well as folks in period costumes and horse-drawn carriages around.
The village itself has a good number of restored buildings including a charming church, a school-house and bar plus houses and outbuildings but we found a lack of details on the history, construction or other information on these buildings rather disappointing.
We enjoyed walking through the grounds and getting a feeling for how local village life used to be but felt it could have been better presented; in all fairness there may have been a visitor information centre but we did not see one during our visit.
If you own or manage Old Bethpage Village Restoration, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.