I used to pass the place on Route 7 for years and didn't think much of the facade. I saw it close and just thought it had closed. Then our friends told us they just moved to the golf course location and they suggested we give it a try as they had been here before (just after they moved).
We (two couples) had dinner on a Saturday night and it was a busy night. The service was average as we had to wait a while several times. We each had the steaks and they were very good and done correctly to our specifications. Prices were reasonable and the atmosphere very nice. We were pleasantly surprised after assuming both the quality of the old place based on the Route 7 facade and finding out that they weren't closed, just moved to the golf course.
We will definitely be back for sure based on this most pleasant experience.
If you own or manage Otis & Oliver's Restaurant, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.