Stayed here for 2 nights in a Marcy room which was lovely but should be at $500/night.. Greeted by front desk clear who had her speech memorized and wasn't going to vary from it. Offered us a bland chocolate chip coffee as she lectured at us instead of answering the questions we asked and wanted answered. The lake staff was lovely and certainly fun to kayak around the lake in the complimentary kayaks. The View Restaurant is absurdly overpriced with entrees averaging in the high 30's with no flavor and average plate design and small portions. Restaurants in NYC or Philadelphia charge the same or less but at least these are award winning chefs and their food have flavor. The view is lovely of the lake but free by day if you want a photo. The afternoon tea which they offer features the same bland chocolate chip cookie not worth the calories from check in which is 20 feet away. Where was the scone, cookie assortment...I kid you not a commercial Milano would have been better. As for the room, they hit you with a chamber maid fee at registration of $7.50 and don't tell you it's optional, wifi was $14.95 for 2 days and free at the Marriott Courtyard down the road where I've stay before. Overall, for $500 for a room to sleep it's living off its reputation and not what is actually delivered.
If you own or manage The View Restaurant at the Mirror Lake Inn, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.