Spent a Sunday doing some wine tasting and touring around the Finger Lakes and my friend, who set up our itinerary, found O'Malleys on the winery map and investigated it a bit to recommend. Given that we were out and about at the wineries somewhat "off season" in early November - not the peak of summer tourist season or fall leaf peeping, it was a bit quieter around the lakes. When we drove up, the place is really cute in a log cabin structure and nicely situated near the lake so there's a good view. We all agreed that it would be good to come back in warmer weather to sit on the deck or out in front in the fun adirondack chiairs and sip wine by the lake.
Anyway, there were 4 of us and everyone really enjoyed their meal. Two friends ordered the special panini of the day - called a "Tom Tom". It included a generous portion of turkey with cheese and red peppers on a nice roll. Another friend ordered their tuna sandwich and although I'm not a tuna fan, this looked really delicious and again, the portion seemed ample. I ordered a cup of lobster bisque and the boneless wings with their special RWB sauce - which is a combo of wing sauce, BBQ and blue cheese. They were really quite delicious and the sauce a nice blend. The lobster bisque was quite delicious as well, with creaminess, good flavor and a nice amount of finely shredded lobster. Overall, I would recommend and am looking forward to trying this place again when the weather gets warmer.
If you own or manage O'Malley's Cabin On the Lake, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.