This was my first trip to the finger lakes and I LOVED it. The Keuka Lakeside Inn added to the great experience of the area. It is right on the water so you can sit outside and enjoy the view for hours if that's your thing, or just enjoy it when the moment arises. There are a few piers as well to relax or even fish if you'd like. They also have a gazebo with chairs. The prices were the best in the area and the location to local business/bars/restaurants were within walking distance.
One thing about the fingers lakes is they don't have much public transportation or cabs. That being said if you want to really cut loose with drinking do your homework and make sure where you are staying is close to bars/restaurants. The Keuka Lakeside Inn is a 5min walk to the town center.
Overall I would highly recommend staying here.