Looks like it should be better than it is.
We thought it would be better than it turned out. Our food was just OK, and the service was, at best, indifferent. Our waiter was ok, but the service seemed disorganized. There was a gaggle of youngsters sort of aimlessly wandering around with water and bread, etc.. Off-putting. The place looks good, and it charges plenty. I see a wide offering of raw oysters, and I imagine that attracts some, but, based on our experience, it is a miss. Pretension without performance is a drag.
If you own or manage North Fork Oyster Company, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.