Anchor Bar is historic and Duff’s is legendary, but Elmo’s might be the best of them all. VERY nondescript place in a plain strip mall just up Millersport from UB, not a destination by any stretch. The hot wings are really good and the honey mustard wings off the grill are out of this world. No history like AB and no crowds like Duff’s but this is the place I’ll keep coming back for wings. Service was fine- nothing special. Dumpy atmosphere, but what are you really looking for in a wing joint? No wet naps to be found and the bathroom is run down. A little touch up here and there could make this place a little easier to recommend.
If you own or manage Elmo's, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.