Overall I think this is a nice restaurant. We ate there the day after July 4th and it was a little busy, but we got in without a reservation placed ahead of time.
The staff was friendly.
The meal took quite a while to arrive. I ordered a sauteed half chicken and it took at least 45 minutes. I was told they didn't think it was cooked enough so they cooked it longer or made another one - I'm not quite sure which. I'm very patient and we were in no rush, so no problem.
The chicken was tasty, though there was more sauce/gravy on the plate than necessary and took over the flavor of the garlic potatoes.
The peanut butter pie-like dessert was tasty.
Overall very good. Everyone liked their meal. For 3 people without alcohol but with dessert and not ordering the most expensive entrees, it was about $85.
If you own or manage Halsey's, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.