I stayed for 2 nights at this property because I live in lower Manhattan and we lost power and water during Sandy. My driver's license is expired (I rarely drive) and it's what I carry as ID in my wallet at all times. While packing for my escape from Manhattan, I didn't think to pack my passport, which is current, as ID. The reservationist never told me they'd need an unexpired form of ID upon checkin. Having spent $40 on a cab to Flushing (all subways and buses were shut down), I arrived to find out that I couldn't check in because my license was expired. I explained to the clerk that I had just come from Manhattan, $40 cab ride, etc. She was unmoved. She left to speak with her manager. The manager never came out. The clerk refused to take my license. In the middle of a storm, I was dumbfounded. This was an extraordinary circumstance and these people made absolutely no effort to figure out a solution. After some back and forth, I remembered that my elderly mother might have her license on her. She did and it wasn't expired. They changed the reservation to her name and we checked in. Unbelievable.
As if that wasn't enough, they didn't have internet. During a storm, I understand that could happen. But when I asked if that was just the hotel or the whole area, the clerk said she didn't know. Later I asked someone else. Again, "I don't know," was the answer. It would be nice, at $299 a night, to get some answers. Even if they didn't have an ETA, to have some information, like whether it was the entire area or not, isn't asking too much. Also, some reassurance would have been nice -- say something like, people were working on it and they hoped to get it up as quickly as possible.
The morning I checked out, front desk told me internet was back. I told her that I had no internet during my stay. There was no offer to discount my bill, coupon, nothing.
Now some positives: the nice housekeeping ladies who gave me shampoo because my room came with none, and offered extra soap and towels. They are also for the nice staff in the restaurant where we had a breakfast buffet (food wasn't great, but surprisingly fairly priced for a hotel), and the nice lobby.
I lived in Flushing for 6 years and this Sheraton is the best hotel (read: not seedy) in the Roosevelt/Main area. It was nice to see they refurbished the rooms and public space. The rooms are basic - clean and comfortable but efficient, with a large writing desk, no minibar, and just the basic amenities. There was a vending machine at the end of the hall for just some soda and water - no price gouging, just $2 a bottle which is fair for a hotel. I just wish the front desk staff was more understanding of my situation. Management should make it a policy for staff not to answer guest questions with just an "I don't know."
Room Tip: Stay away from rooms near elevators. Ours was directly in front of them and the noise was endless...
See more room tips
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.
November 9, 2012
Dear Dgfvsxz,
Thank you for taking the time to express your concerns, While I am happy to hear that you were satisfied with your accommodations, our property and our décor I am quite concerned with the challenges you experienced upon check in. I agree that one has to have understanding and compassion, especially during a critical period such as hurricane Sandy. It is disappointing that you did not experience that. I also agree that answering any questions with an “I don’t know” is not acceptable. I apologize for the way your check in was handled and that you were not properly informed of our internet issues. To clarify that point, due to the storm a lot of our area of queens lost internet due to our provider’s central station took on water. We did not have any ETA of when it may be restored but you could have a least been informed that the issue was not specific to our property rather our area and it was being worked on.
We pride ourselves on delivering a high level of service and it is unfortunate that is not what you experienced. I would like to discuss further with you the challenges you encountered to get more details. Please contact me, at your convenience, at hotelmanager@sheratonlaguardia.com. Please provide me your contact information and when would be the best time to reach you. I look forward to hearing from you.
With Warm Regards,
Ed S.
General Manager
Report response as inappropriate
This response is the subjective opinion of the management representative and not of TripAdvisor LLC.