We live in the Hamptons year round, and absolutely love this place. It's like a neighborhood Cheers with excellent food. Yes it is packed in the season, but that's because it's one of a handful of places that is deserving of its reputation. The managers are wonderful, bartenders are great, and the servers are friendly, helpful and very competent, and btw the food is delish. Definitely try the biscuits (you can always buy bigger pants in town) and the oysters (their version of Rockefeller). Dover sole, prime rib, pretty much every main course is fantastic.
If you own or manage East Hampton Grill, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.