The Roycroft Inn and East Aurora are absolutely delightful. We ended up there because we wanted a Niagara get a way week end and everything in Niagara on the Lake was booked. At the time I thought it was a bit of a roll of the dice but we could not have been happier with the end result. Such a great spot. The rooms are spare but if you love Arts and Crafts design you will love this place. I was also very impressed with the size of the rooms. We stayed in a four room suite and wow, it's bigger than most condo's!
As a runner I also found East Aurora to be a real delight. There are lots of beautiful houses to look at and it takes no time to get on to the trails at Knox Hill farm State Park if you prefer trails to roads.
This place is a gem! Go visit.