Went here for dinner at recommendation of our B&B hosts. Downtown location on main street near Hall of Fame. Restaurant interior was nice but standard, but we sat outside in back and it was idyllic - surrounded by foliage and covered by umbrellas on a beautiful summer evening. Ask to sit out back! (But don't look outside the patio since you are right next to a parking lot - though there was no traffic or noise and we noticed only because we looked.)
Food was great - best meal of our week vacation (agreed to by all 4 adults in our group). Portions were very large - locals have an advantage here as they can take leftovers home).
If you own or manage Nicoletta's Italian Cafe, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.