Amazing proportions; fast and friendly service; and delicious food. Our experience at the Pepper Mill in Cooperstown was very enjoyable. We started with the salad bar, which had a lot of tasty options (they even make their own dressing in house). We then had the crab cakes - they were very sizable for an appetizer and very good. Our meals were impressive: my steak was tender and flavorful, the mashed potatoes were rich and buttery, and I had enough left over for another meal the next day! My dinning partner had the stuffed chicken parm, which was equally as good and equally as large - the chicken was tender, the sauce was homemade, and the meal had a great flavor.
To sum it up: great meal, great service.
If you own or manage Pepper Mill, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.