We had never eaten at Artie's before, but after reading very positive reviews we made reservations for Christmas Eve. We were seated in the smaller of three dining rooms. Our waitress took our order efficiently, and served our drinks promptly. Although we were a party of six, we ordered enough appetizers for eight! We should have stopped there, because they were generous portions--and delicious! Speaking for myself, my eyes were bigger than my stomach, and we then ordered our entrees. Each entree looked better than the next!! Okay, so I forced myself to finish every last drop of mine (Fruta de Mare)!! Absolutely wonderful! My wife had the whole snapper. Beautiful presentation! Others had the Captain's Platter, the Tuna, and Chilean Sea Bass. All I can say is that if you want to enjoy a delicious mean in a warm and friendly atmosphere, take a ride to City Island and go directly to Artie's. Mangia, Mangia!
If you own or manage Artie's Steak & Seafood, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.