Went for dinner with my inlaws. They apparentley had a party that was leaving and were unable to seat us. We decided to wait since we were there first and figured they would seat us first. Other customers started to come in. After about 20 minutes they started seating. They seated several 2 seat tables before us and then seated a 4 person group(two of whom were small children) that had come in after us. After several more minutes the hostess finally approached us and told us there were no seates available and since they had other reservations for an hour later they would not serve us. So, they make us wait 40 minutes with two elderly people only to seat others before us and tell us they cant serve us. I have had bad service there in the past, but the food is pallatable which is rare for the Brewster area, but this is just rude and unprofessional. I will not go there any more, not even for a slice. I have been a customer of theirs for years, but they have clearly gotten too big for their own good and the service and quality of food has suffered
We wound up going to the new Grill restaurant at Clocktower and that food and service was excellent
If you own or manage AVERSANO'S, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.