We visited the restaurant on September 12th this year. I used the reviews on Tripadvisor to give Jersey Girl a shot and we were very pleased with our experience here.
I ordered the New York Strip steak and my Gf ordered one of the specials of the night which was penne pasta in a vodka sauce with crab meat. I had the salad with my meal and she upgraded to the seafood chowder. After we received our soup and salad the waitress returned to our table and asked my Gf if she could remove and replace her soup. When we questioned the move she informed us that the chef did not want the soup from that particular pot to be served because it was not up to his standard. The soup she brought back was nothing short of "Wow".........so much seafood and tortellini it was hard to get a spoon to the bottom of the bowl. We were impressed with this offer.
Long story short........service was excellent, food was excellent and prices were very reasonable for the overall experience. We will return next year!