We met another couple for a casual dinner at Atlantic Manor, and it turned out to be a wonderful time and fun experience. We sat for a drink at an inviting bar while waiting for the other couple to arrive, and in discussing this restaurant with regulars there, it became clear that each person has their favorites from among a menu that offers a wide variety. As has been mentioned in a few other reviews here, the shrimp and garlic is a favorite, and I'd agree, since I had that, too -- it was delicious. One couple at the bar swore by the barbecued chicken dish, calling it the best ever. Other people in my group had steak dishes and enjoyed them. We all liked, in traditional Portuguese restaurant style, how the side dishes of potatoes or rice and veggies were plentiful. Only downside was the service, and maybe we caught them on a bad night when they weren't fully staffed ... but our bartender at the beginning also would up being our waitress in the dining room. She had a lot to handle and did her best, but a lot of people there were kept waiting for food and drinks to be served and water glasses to be refilled, and any questions to be answered. I'd definitely go back, though.
If you own or manage Atlantic Manor, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.