My wife and I ate at Spanish Tavern early in January. The experience was simply excellent.
Server: Wilbur (yes, “Wilbur” - - ask him how he got the name!) could not have been better. Very attentive and informative.
Food: Meal started with the complimentary bowl (not cup) of soup - - nice touch and excellent. We shared the shrimp in garlic sauce appetizer (as so many reviewers raved about it) - - it did not disappoint. For our entre, we opted to share an order of paella (Wilbur assured us that it would be enough for two - - and it was). My wife inquired if it might be “too spicy” – not to her taste – while I indicated that I preferred “spicy” and Wilbur suggested that he bring out a “side bowl” of a “spicier sauce” that I could add to my share. How often do you get a server who will even listen to his customers, let alone go out of his way to make the experience memorable. Bottom line - - wife and I both loved our entre. Pitcher of sangria was a perfect match. Flan for desert was to die for - - at least as good as all others who raved about it. To make up for sangria arriving a bit late, Wilbur offered complimentary dessert wine. Another “above and beyond” touch.
Ambiance: Really very nice, although a bit crowded (but less so than other Ironbound restaurants as we’ve heard). Free, attended parking lot across the street was another very nice touch.
Price: I have eaten in restaurants in 13 different countries and this experience was one of the best value dinners I have experienced - - total bill was under $70 including a very handsome tip.
Can’t wait for my next excuse to be in the Newark area to return to Spanish Tavern.
If you own or manage Spanish Tavern, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.