I have been coming here for many years and would say most of what I have seen has been a winner. The five shows every season offer a bit of everything -- drama, comedy, sometimes a musical. I've seen shows that were big hits on Broadway just a few years ago. The casts are generally excellent (you'll sometimes catch some big names) and the sets are gorgeous. This is a smallish theater, with about 350 seats. On-street parking in New Brunswick can be a hassle, but there are garages and the theater is only a quick walk from the New Brunswick train station.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.