Went here during our stay in Cape May over Father's Day weekend. It came highly recommended and I have to second the motion! When we arrived it seemed there would be a lengthy wait based on the crowd outside, but they do a good job of getting people in and out without feeling rushed. It's also a much bigger place than it appears from the street.
They have buttermilk and oatmeal pancake batter and both are very tasty. Our five-year old finished them all which he rarely does. (He eats a good variety of foods, but rarely a lot.) I went with the old standard "Country Breakfast." Eggs, bacon, homefries, toast. All very good. i know you may think, "how can you screw that up." I agree, it's tough, but oftentimes it's not really good and this WAS REALLY GOOD.
The service was fantastic. Very friendly, efficient and quick to fill your coffee cup! I would consider staying in Cape May again just to go to the Mad Batter.
If you own or manage Mad Batter at the Carroll Villa, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.