My husband and I have dined here three times. Each time we were served exquisite meals, whether they be fish or meat. The sauces are amazing and the portions just right. The waitstaff is extraordinary! We noticed that for one large party, the waitstaff joined together to serve the meals simultaneously so no one needed to wait for others to be served. A nice touch! The waitstaff was similarly attentive to smaller parties. In passing, we mentioned to the server that it was my husband's birthday, and she surprised us with a complimentary dessert complete with a candle! The restaurant is a bit pricey, but is in line with the rest of Cape May. And because it's a BYO, the cost can be contained and we actually spent less here than at other restaurants. You can't go wrong at this elegant but not stuffy restaurant; arguably the best dinner in Cape May.
If you own or manage Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.