Disclaimer: We stayed at the Red Jacket Inn and went to Kahuna Laguna on Superbowl Sunday & the next day. There was virtually no one there. We had the place to ourselves so I don't know that your experience will mirror ours.
Didn't go to Tiki Cafe, and it was closed on Monday.
We took our 4 1/2 yr old and loved it. It was very clean, the lifegaurds were alert and courteous. the wave pool was very fun. The water is clorinated salt water which was more pleasing than stright pool water. Towels were abundant as was seating but seating looks sparse I think for a packed water park. The slides are GREAT! 2 tube slides which we used with our daughter and 2 slides that were a little scarier and not suitable for her height or age.
It is not dangerous as one reviewer mentioned. There are no sharp corners but if a child falls the ground is slightly abrasive (so as not to be slippery) so there will be scrapes.
Red Jacket was a deal too at 109 a night including our tickets and breakfast. Will def go back.
If you own or manage Kahuna Laguna, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.