My wife and I hiked up to stay at the Carter Notch Hut in October once the full-service season was over. It's a lot cheaper but you need to pack all your own food and bedding. We stayed on a Friday night and were the only guests, save for the 20-something caretaker who was a very nice guy.
If you are an adventurous sort and don't mind preparing your food and sleeping in an unheated bunkhouse, you'll love the huts in the off-season! From what I could tell, Saturdays are often still busy but if you go during the week you may have the whole place to yourself. Bankhouse/hut was clean and kitchen was awesome. Highly recommended.
If you own or manage Appalachian Mountain Club High Huts, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.